1 · The friction
What owners assume
These are common assumptions. The test below looked at which cafés were named and which sources were listed. It did not test each belief.
“It's all about Instagram”
Many owners believe social media is what gets them recommended.
A common assumption. We noted which sources were listed.
“Reviews don't matter much”
Some owners assume ratings and reviews carry little weight.
A common assumption. We noted which review sites were listed.
“If the coffee's good, people will find us”
Many owners believe quality alone gets them recommended.
A common assumption. The test cannot measure quality.
2 · The numbers
What we found
Limits: one run per question per day, over two days, run by Tift. AI answers change from run to run, so another run could differ.
41
Cafés named by ChatGPT across 10 suburbs on 10 Nov. On 14 Nov it named 33 of them again, and Google AI Mode named 19.
Tift field tests, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
10/10
Answers on 10 Nov that listed a guide, list or review site among their sources. On 14 Nov: 7 of the 7 ChatGPT answers we could check, and 1 of 10 for Google AI Mode.
Tift field tests, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
7/10
Answers on 10 Nov that listed an editorial guide, meaning a magazine or media guide such as Time Out, Broadsheet or Australian Traveller. On 14 Nov: 6 of 7 for ChatGPT (Broadsheet, Man of Many or Urban List), 0 of 10 for Google AI Mode.
Tift field tests, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
0/10
Answers on 10 Nov that listed a café's own website or Instagram. On 14 Nov this did not hold: 3 of 7 ChatGPT answers we could check, and 2 of 10 for Google AI Mode.
Tift field tests, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
On 10 Nov, ChatGPT's answers pointed to the guides and review sites that already rate cafés. On 14 Nov that still held for ChatGPT, but not cleanly: some answers also listed a café's own site. Google AI Mode showed few sources at all. Ten answers per tool cannot tell us why a café is named. We can say which sources were listed: guides and review sites, most often.
3 · How we tested it
The method
Pick 10 suburbs
A spread across Sydney: inner city, east, west, north and south. Surry Hills, Newtown, Bondi, Parramatta, Manly, Chatswood, Marrickville, Cronulla, Penrith and Balmain.
Ask ChatGPT the same question
“What's the best café in your suburb?” in ChatGPT on 10 Nov 2026. On 10 Nov we were signed in to a free account and used a temporary chat. We also tried Perplexity logged out, which stopped after 2 questions.
Record who was named
Every café named, in order, with screenshots kept as evidence on 10 Nov. On 14 Nov the answers were saved as text, not screenshots.
Check what they had in common
Which sites each answer listed among its sources, and the ratings and awards it repeated.
Run it again on 14 Nov
The same 10 questions, word for word, on 14 Nov 2026. On 14 Nov we used a temporary chat without signing in. We also added Google AI Mode, signed in with personalisation off. It had no 10 Nov run, so it has no baseline. One run per question each day.
Day two, 14 Nov 2026
ChatGPT named 33 of the 41 cafés again and 17 new ones, 50 names in all. Google AI Mode named 19 of the 41, 61 names in all. Between them they named 34 of the 41. In the same suburb, both tools named 25 of the same cafés.
The raw results, 10 Nov 2026, with 14 Nov repeats
Surry Hills
Single O, Reuben Hills, A.P. Bakery, Four Ate Five
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Time Out. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 3 of these 4 again and Google AI Mode named 1 of 4.
Newtown
Brewtown, Campos Coffee, Shenkin
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Sitchu. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 1 of these 3 again and Google AI Mode named 0 of 3.
Bondi
bills, Speedos Café, Harry's, Shuk, Gertrude & Alice
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Visit Bondi Beach. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 4 of these 5 again and Google AI Mode named 0 of 5.
Parramatta
Circa Espresso, Homage
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Time Out People's Choice, All Fives. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 2 of these 2 again and Google AI Mode named 2 of 2.
Manly
Showbox Coffee, Fika, Little Legends, Wolfies
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Google ratings, Tripadvisor. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 4 of these 4 again and Google AI Mode named 1 of 4.
Chatswood
Cafe Markus, Black Potion, Apothecary Coffee, Chimichuri
Sources listed on 10 Nov: NearMe, Tripadvisor. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 4 of these 4 again and Google AI Mode named 4 of 4.
Marrickville
ONA Coffee, Algorithm, Two Chaps, Double Tap, Angus, SIT
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Broadsheet. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 5 of these 6 again and Google AI Mode named 2 of 6.
Cronulla
Grind Espresso, Blackwood, Next Door, Little's, LOAF
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Australian Traveller. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 4 of these 5 again and Google AI Mode named 3 of 5.
Penrith
The T-Spoon, Underground Coffee Roasters, Henri Marc, 4oz & Co
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Fair Measure, Tripadvisor, All Fives. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 3 of these 4 again and Google AI Mode named 3 of 4.
Balmain
Home Croissanterie, Phono Stage, Contessa, little Ethel's
Sources listed on 10 Nov: Tripadvisor, NearMe, MenuMap. On 14 Nov, ChatGPT named 3 of these 4 again and Google AI Mode named 3 of 4.
4 · The decision
What the named cafés had in common, 10 Nov
This is how the 10 Nov answers looked. We did not re-score these on 14 Nov, apart from the own-website and Instagram point.
Almost all had
A place on a local guide or review site
Strong ratings, where ratings were shown
A clear name and suburb
Most had
A mention in a dated list, like a 2025 or 2026 guide
An award or People's Choice win
Something specific to quote, like a signature dish
Didn't show up on 10 Nov
The café's own Instagram. On 14 Nov, Google AI Mode linked a café's site or social page in 2 of 10 answers
The café's own website, on its own. On 14 Nov, 3 of the 7 ChatGPT answers we could check listed one among their sources
5 · From our work
The short version
Challenge
Which cafés do AI tools name in Sydney, and which sources do they list?
Action
Same question, 10 suburbs, on 10 Nov and again on 14 Nov. Every answer recorded.
Result
3/7
ChatGPT answers we could check on 14 Nov that listed a café's own website among their sources. On 10 Nov it was 0 of 10. Guides and review sites were still listed in all 7.
6 · Quick answers
Questions owners ask us
Can I see the raw data?
Yes. The café names for every suburb are listed above, with the sources we saw on 10 Nov. We kept screenshots of the 10 Nov answers and saved the 14 Nov answers as text. We'll share either on request.
Will you run this for my business?
Yes. Tell us your business and suburb and we'll check what AI tools say about you.
Will you run it again?
We did. On 14 Nov we asked the same questions again in ChatGPT and added Google AI Mode. We also tried Perplexity on 10 Nov, but stopped after 2 questions. AI answers change, so each run is a snapshot.
How solid are these results?
They are a snapshot. One run per question each day, two days, run by Tift. On 10 Nov we were signed in to a free account and used a temporary chat. On 14 Nov we used a temporary chat without signing in. That alone can change answers. Three of the 14 Nov ChatGPT answers were saved without their source lists, so source counts are out of 7.