1 · The friction
What owners assume
We tested these beliefs instead of guessing.
“Lead sites are the only way”
Many tradies believe they need paid lead sites to be found.
Source: What owners tell us
“The big franchises always win”
Owners assume the biggest ad budget wins every search.
Source: What owners tell us
“Nobody asks ChatGPT for a tradie”
Many tradies believe AI tools don't matter for local work.
Source: What owners tell us
2 · The numbers
What we found
38
Electricians ChatGPT named on 10 Nov. On 14 Nov it named 20 of them again
Tift field test, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
10/10
ChatGPT top picks that advertised 24/7 emergency service, on 10 Nov and again on 14 Nov
Tift field test, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
0/10
Answers that listed a guide or magazine among their sources, on 10 Nov and in both tools on 14 Nov
Tift field test, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
10/10
Answers that asked what the emergency was before choosing, on 10 Nov and in both tools on 14 Nov
Tift field test, 10 and 14 Nov 2026
The names changed a lot between days, but what ChatGPT's top picks showed did not. On both days each of the 10 had 24/7 service on show, and a Google rating of 4.9 or 5.0 was shown for 9 of 10 on 10 Nov and 10 of 10 on 14 Nov. That does not prove it is why they were picked. It is what to keep clear and current: your hours, your suburbs, your licence and your callout terms.
3 · How we tested it
The method
Pick 10 suburbs
A spread across Sydney: inner city, east, west, north and south. Surry Hills, Newtown, Bondi, Parramatta, Manly, Chatswood, Marrickville, Cronulla, Penrith and Balmain.
Ask ChatGPT the same question
“Who's a good emergency electrician in your suburb?” in ChatGPT on 10 Nov 2026, from a free account in a temporary chat.
Record who was named
Every electrician named, in order, with screenshots kept as evidence.
Check what they had in common
Google rating and review count, and which details from the electrician's own website or profile it repeated.
Run it again on 14 Nov, with Google AI Mode added
The same question, word for word, in the same 10 suburbs, on Saturday 14 Nov 2026 between about 4:30 pm and 6:30 pm Sydney time. ChatGPT in a temporary chat, not signed in. Google AI Mode signed in, with personalisation off. Google AI Mode was not run on 10 Nov, so it has no baseline. For Google, “named again” means it also recommends a name from the 10 Nov list. It does not show Google's answers changed. The 14 Nov answers were saved as text, not screenshots.
Know the limits
One run per question per day, over two days, run by Tift. AI answers change from run to run, so one run cannot separate a real change from ordinary variation. On 10 Nov ChatGPT was a signed-in free account in a temporary chat. On 14 Nov it was not signed in, so part of the ChatGPT change may come from the setup.
Day two, 14 Nov 2026
ChatGPT named 20 of the 38 electricians again. Google AI Mode named 18 of them. Together the two tools named 24 of the 38. ChatGPT gave 34 names in all and Google AI Mode gave 50. 21 electricians were named by both tools for the same suburb on 14 Nov. The 14 Nov answers are saved and can be shared on request. Of the three field tests we reran, this is where ChatGPT's names changed most between days (cafés 33 of 41 repeated, e-bikes 29 of 40). What was the same on both days for ChatGPT's top picks: all 10 advertised 24/7. Their rating of 4.9 or 5.0 was shown for 9 of 10 on 10 Nov and 10 of 10 on 14 Nov. In Google AI Mode all 10 answers opened with 24-hour or 24/7 wording, and the top pick's own entry said it in 6 of 10. Google AI Mode showed a rating for 7 of 10 top picks, and all seven were 5.0. Neither tool listed a guide or magazine among its sources (0 of 10 each). Both asked what the emergency was (10 of 10 each). Google AI Mode also linked Ausgrid, the network operator, or the NSW government in 6 of 10 answers.
The raw results, 10 Nov 2026, with how many names came back on 14 Nov
Surry Hills
ABX Electrical, AGT Power, Surry Hills Electrical, High Demand Electrical
Signals: Google ratings, 24/7, phone. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 3 from this list.
Newtown
Powertech Electrical Group, Braytech Electrical, Empire Electrical Contractors
Signals: Google reviews, $0 callout fee. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 1 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 4, 1 from this list.
Bondi
Ambient Electrical, Bondi Electrician, Bright Force Electrical, Dr Emergency Electrician
Signals: licence number, owner name, 1-hour attendance. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 4 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 1 from this list.
Parramatta
Amazed Electrical, Electric Air Services, Quick Time Electrical, SBS Electrical Service
Signals: hipages ratings, NearMe. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 1 from this list.
Manly
AB Electrical & Communications, Electric Express, Manly Electrical, Whale Shark Electrical, Daniel Scope Electrical
Signals: Master Electricians, 2-hour response. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 1 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 6, 2 from this list.
Chatswood
North Shore Electrician, Sparkfix Electrical, Ruttley Services, 360 Degrees Sydney Electrical
Signals: licence number, street address. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 4 names, 3 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 2 from this list.
Marrickville
Marrickville Electrical Services, Mr Sparky, ETS Electrical
Signals: local address, Level 2 ASP. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 4 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 1 from this list.
Cronulla
SOS Electrical, Cronulla Electrical, Skyco Trades
Signals: Google reviews, upfront pricing, NearMe. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 4, 2 from this list.
Penrith
Flash Electrical & Data, Leonay Electrical, Penrith Electrical
Signals: map card, licence numbers. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 4 names, 3 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 6, 3 from this list.
Balmain
Protech Maintenance Electrical, Innerwest Electrical Solutions, Lightning Electrical Group, Balmain Electrical, Empire Electrical Contractors
Signals: Google profile, suburb page on own website. 14 Nov: ChatGPT gave 3 names, 2 from this list. Google AI Mode gave 5, 2 from this list.
4 · The decision
What the named electricians had in common on 10 Nov
Almost all had
24/7 emergency service stated clearly
A Google rating of 4.7 or higher, where one was shown (all named electricians, not just top picks)
A phone number and suburb on the profile
Most had
A licence number, address or owner name to quote
A response-time or callout-fee promise
A page naming the suburbs they cover
Not listed in the sources
Guides and magazines, none were listed among the sources
5 · From our work
The short version
Challenge
Which electricians do AI tools recommend in Sydney, and do the names stay the same from day to day?
Action
Same question, 10 suburbs. ChatGPT on 10 Nov, then ChatGPT and Google AI Mode on 14 Nov. Every answer recorded.
Result
20/38
Names ChatGPT repeated on day two. Its top picks showed the same 24/7 wording on both days, with a high rating on 9 of 10 (10 Nov) and 10 of 10 (14 Nov).
6 · Quick answers
Questions owners ask us
Can I see the raw data?
Yes. The 10 Nov names for every suburb are listed above, with how many came back on 14 Nov. We kept screenshots of the 10 Nov answers. The 14 Nov answers were saved as text, not screenshots, and the names on that day are not listed on this page. We'll share the saved answers on request.
Will you run this for my business?
Yes. Tell us your business and suburb and we'll check what AI tools say about you.
Does 24/7 wording and a high rating make an electrician get picked?
We can't say. Those signals were on show for ChatGPT's top picks on both days, but one run per question per day cannot show cause. Keep them clear and accurate anyway.
Will you run it again?
We did, on 14 Nov, with Google AI Mode added. Gemini and Perplexity are still to come, then we repeat every few months, because AI answers change.